Using Taxation to Win-Win-Win!

The battle over to what extent smokers should be free to exercise their legal right to smoke a legal product is one area of modern concern. In this battle most of the areas smoker’s “control” is becoming smaller and smaller. Pretty much inside any building or any place where minors may gather is forbidden territory, protected by law or local rules. But the battle is over how much smokers alone must contribute to paying for the recognized negative health and societal effects of their habit remains a perennial budgetary issue, both at the state and national level. And a time where so many entitlements have been established, and so many have been financially stressed by the economic depression of the last five years, the opportunity to impose additional taxes on smokers seems the “cure-all for lawmaker’s revenue problems.”

As Peter Hirschfeld reports for The Barre Montpelier Times Argus, “Increasing the excise tax on cigarettes by $1.25 per pack . . . will not only close the budget gap and save $116 million in avoided health care costs, but also will win legislators points with voters back home.”

But businesses that sell this legal product to adults only see this as an economic body blow. The current surcharge on cigarettes places Vermont as the eighth-highest in the nation. This draws in smokers from New York and Massachusetts which have the first and second-highest tax on cigarettes. But neighbor New Hampshire is a dollar cheaper than Vermont and if Vermont goes even higher then New York and Massachusetts smokers may bypass Vermont altogether.

But the goal of the anti-tobacco groups is reduction and elimination. Kevin O’Flaherty, the Northeast’s regional advocacy director of the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids says, “Significant cigarette tax increases are the single most effective way to reduce smoking across the entire population, but especially among youth.” And a study by the Institute for Health Research and Policy (University of Illinois at Chicago), tracked smoking rates in Vermont from 1995 and 2010. The state excise taxes went from $0.20 a pack to $2.62 a pack. But smoking rates dropped by over 30 percent, from 22.1 percent to 15.4 percent. People just quit.

The message seems to be whether on a national, state or local level: we are not criminalizing your activity nor forbidding it everywhere. The seeds that were planted have come to full bloom and the tax man wants an ever larger portion for the costs foisted on society. Smokers are being increasingly asked whether their simply enjoying a private vice does not also demand they pay their share of the wide-spread negative societal and health consequences.


The contents of the web site (the "Site") are for informational purposes only. The Information is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, tests or treatment, and does not create a physician-patient relationship. This Site and Deep Dive Media ("the Company") are not responsible for sending you to, referring you to or making recommendations about a doctor, a professional practice or health insurance company. NO LICENSED PHYSICIAN-PATIENT RELATIONSHIP IS CREATED BY USING INFORMATION PROVIDED BY OR THROUGH THE USE OF THIS SITE INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, TREATMENT CENTER REFERRAL FUNCTIONS OR LINKS TO OTHER SITES. The Company makes no guarantees, representations or warranties, whether expressed or implied, with respect to professional qualifications, expertise, quality of work or other information herein. Further the Company does not in any way endorse the individuals described herein. In no event shall the Company be liable to you or anyone else for any decision made or action taken by you in reliance on such information. You are STRONGLY ADVISED to perform your own due diligence prior to selecting a health care professional with activities, such as making confirming telephone calls to the appropriate licensing authorities to verify listed credentials and education. In addition you can further verify information about a physician or medical provider by confirming with the doctor's office, your current physician, the medical association relative to the doctor's specialty and your state medical board. See our Legal Statement for the complete terms and conditions governing your use of the Site.


Why Did You Visit This Site?
I am looking for treatment
A friend or family member is looking for treatment
Just Looking for Information
Total votes: 101
Call 1-855-216-4673 anytime to speak with an addiction specialist. Insurance Accepted.